2007年7月26日星期四
2007年5月25日星期五
How to think about life
![](http://bp3.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RleFsOrmfuI/AAAAAAAAAIU/3XUwpuNBtvI/s0-d/soc_uefachamps_751t.jpg)
2007年5月7日星期一
Jon Elster
![](http://bp1.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rj_C0MRI0qI/AAAAAAAAAH8/5McSVp_F5Ac/s0-d/jon+elster.jpg)
交流的价值
2007年5月3日星期四
加里·贝克尔(Gary S.Becker)
![](http://bp1.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RjohScRI0oI/AAAAAAAAAHs/uNHBy4vYMJE/s0-d/becker.jpg)
贝克尔是现代经济学领域中最有创见的思想家之一,因其在人力资本、家庭经济学、犯罪的经济学分析、歧视、人口等方面的研究著称。他的很多成果中国已经出版,例如《口味的经济学分析》、《人类行为的经济学分析》、《生活的经济学》《家庭论》等。
1992年,贝克尔被授予诺贝尔经济学奖,其贡献为“将经济理论扩展到对人类相互行为的分析,包括对非市场行为的分析。” 贝克尔将经济学理性假设的分析方法创建性的引入到如下的四个领域,对无论是经济学、人口学还有社会学分析方法产生了巨大而深远的影响:(1)人口资本的投资问题;(2)家庭行为的解释;(3)犯罪行为和惩罚;(4)劳动力和商品市场上面的歧视问题。
2007年4月18日星期三
2007年3月3日星期六
Multiple-level theory
2007年3月2日星期五
Statistical tests
![](http://bp0.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rejywtj8tzI/AAAAAAAAAG4/HzKNpFmIxu0/s0-d/Architect+Skype.png)
Statistical tests of the predicted homogeneity, independence, or heterogeneity of a measure fall into two rough categories:
a. those that assess the extent of agreement within a single group and
b. those that assess the extent of agreement (or reliability) by contrasting within-and between-group variance.
1. James, Demaree, and Wolf's (1984) Iwg typifies the first category.
2. the second category includes analysis-of-variance models and their related measures of association such as
a. eta-squared (Dansereau et al., 1984) and
b. different forms of the intraclass correlation (Glick, 1985; Kenny & La Voie, 1985; Maxwell, Camp, & Arvey, 1981)
Although they employ differing criteria, these indicators are designed to answer a common question:
Does the variability within groups differ from what would be expected by chance?
2007年2月16日星期五
zz 季羡林:谁觉得自己是大师,他就自己承认好了
他96岁,只有一只眼睛有视力,每日清晨4时起,坐在床上拿只放大镜,用钢笔写“比较文学史”。手边一本书也没有,不用查资料,“写了一辈子,我就是干这一行的”。
医生不让他下地行走,骨髓炎,据说是跟十几年前一件事有关。
那年他78岁,要去开会,发现被锁在家里,1米8的高度,他比划下自己1米72的身高,就跳下去了。后来检查骨裂了。
同去的女孩说唉呀。
他带点炫耀的自嘲“有点冒进,有点冒进”
这个宣统三年出生的人。经过清朝,经过袁世凯的洪宪,经过国民党的统治,一直到解放,一直到走过“手臂举起象树林一样的天安门”…说起这一段,还是象个孩子。
医生一共只让我们聊12分钟,所以在临别时才跟他谈起胡适,他谈兴很浓,说到当年批判胡适,他写文章为胡正名,出发点既不是政治,也不是学术,也不谈旧情,只是因为他觉得胡适是个“好人”
“不管是大人物还是小人物,评价一个人,过分不好,歪曲也不好,而且要让每个人都可以有自由发表他的意见”
他谈的都是常识。
可惜常识是这个时代稀缺的东西。
2007年2月15日星期四
Anne Huff
![](http://bp2.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RdURQsKpfII/AAAAAAAAAGs/2iYGupxMsCo/s0-d/ahuff_7.jpg)
Anne Sigismund Huff is the Founding Director of the Advanced Institute of Management Research (AIM), a UK wide management research initiative with offices based at the London Business School.
In 1998-99 she was President of the Academy of Management, an international organization of over 13,000 scholars interested in management issues.
2007年2月13日星期二
Edward Paul Lazear
2007年2月12日星期一
James Coleman
2007年2月11日星期日
Christopher K. Hsee
![](http://bp1.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rc9Cv8KpfGI/AAAAAAAAAGU/pa0aEj5VL0k/s0-d/329586.jpg)
Education
A.B. (psychology), University of Hawaii, 1989; Ph.D. (psychology), Yale University, 1993.
Selected Publications
With R. Hastie, "Decision and Experience," Trends in Cognitive Sciences (2006). With F. Leclerc et al., "Narrow focusing: Why the relative position of a product within a category matters more than it should?," Marketing Science (2005). With J. Zhang, "Distinction bias: Misprediction and mischoice due to joint evaluation," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (2004). With Y. Rottenstreich, "Music, pandas and muggers: On the affective psychology of value," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General (2004).
2007年2月9日星期五
Dennis W. Organ
The Lives of Others
![](http://bp1.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rc1j3cKpfEI/AAAAAAAAAF8/aC5VCgqDkJU/s0-d/th-02.jpg)
![](file:///C:/DOCUME%7E1/freeman/LOCALS%7E1/Temp/moz-screenshot.jpg)
2007年2月6日星期二
Benjamin Schneider
![](http://bp3.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RclLcd-D6rI/AAAAAAAAAFw/KaRBYPijVqc/s0-d/ben.jpg)
Benjamin Schneider is Professor of Psychology at the University of Maryland and Chair of the Industrial and Organizational Psychology Program.
Ben has two major streams of research, each of which has several subcategories. One research stream concerns the role of manager personality in understanding the structure, strategy, and climate/culture of organizations. This research program is based on a series of papers Ben did in the 1980s culminating in a piece called "The People Make the Place" (Personnel Psychology, 1987). Since then Ben has written several conceptual pieces on what has come to be called the ASA framework.
His second stream of research concerns research directed at understanding organizational designs for service quality. In this work Ben early demonstrated the linkage between employee experiences of work and the service quality experiences of the customers they serve. Ben and his colleagues (as well as others), have subsequently replicated this work several times (see Schneider, White and Paul, Journal of Applied Psychology, 1998). This research has resulted in numerous journal publications related to service quality and also to organizational climate. Thus, the research on employees of service organizations has had organizational climate as a foundation construct.
2007年2月5日星期一
Richard L. Daft
![](http://bp3.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RcdZt9-D6jI/AAAAAAAAAEQ/k3tP96wB_co/s0-d/96photo.jpg)
Discipline(s):
- Leadership and Communications
- Organization Studies and Human Resources Management
Area(s) of Expertise:
Leadership, transformational communication and change management.
Research Interest(s):
Leadership mental models, change management and the design of performance-driven systems for large organizations.
Education:
B.S., University of Nebraska, 1967
M.B.A., University of Chicago, 1971
Ph.D., University of Chicago, 1974
2007年2月4日星期日
林 南
![](http://bp2.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rca359-D6hI/AAAAAAAAAD4/1xWR4k8w2TU/s0-d/linnan.gif)
生日:1938年8月21日
学历:东海大学学士(1960)
Syracuse University碩士(1963)
Michigan State University博士(1966)
经历:Johns Hopkins University助理教授
State University of New York at Albany副教授、正教授、系主任
Duke University社会系正教授、亚洲太平洋研究所所长
专长:社会学
荣誉:美国社会学会副会长
“我认为社会科学研究者有两个目标,一个是在我们的学科中留一点「痕迹」,就是让以后的人知道自己的研究;第二个是留下「轨迹」,这更不容易了,要让后面 的人跟著你走,我常常提醒自己不要认为现在已经做的差不多了,有点痕迹不要自满,我们应该抱著留下轨迹的心情,而不只是要造成一时的轰动 (sensation),我常这样鼓励我自己及学生。”
JON ELSTER
![](http://bp2.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RcXP-N-D6gI/AAAAAAAAADs/uRyYPzHl8xw/s0-d/faculty.jpg)
JON ELSTER
ROBERT K. MERTON PROFESSOR OF SOCIAL SCIENCES
Columbia University
POLITICAL SCIENCE
Biography
Jon Elster (Ph.D., University of Paris, 1972) Before coming to Columbia University, he taught at Paris, Oslo and Chicago. His publications include Ulysses and the Sirens (1979), Sour Grapes (1983), Making Sense of Marx (1985), The Cement of Society (1989), Solomonic Judgements (1989), Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences (1989), Local Justice (1992), Political Psychology (1993), Alchemies of the Mind (1999), Ulysses Unbound (2000) and Closing the Books: Transitional Justice in Historical Perspective (2004). His research interests include the theory of rational choice, the theory of distributive justice and the history of social thought (Marx and Tocqueville). He is currently working on a comparative study of constitution-making processes from the Federal Convention to the present, besides being engaged in a project on the microfoundations of civil war.
Research Interests: Constitution-Making, Theory of Rational Choice, History of Political Thought (Tocqueville and Marx), Empirical Studies of Justice, Emotions and Social Theory.
2007年2月3日星期六
Xiao-Ping Chen
![](http://bp1.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RcU3l9-D6fI/AAAAAAAAADg/x-5Vr06jsBc/s0-d/Chen_Xiaoping_pf.jpg)
Professor of Management & Organization
Evert McCabe Fellow
Co-chair of Management and Organization Department
PhD, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1995
MA, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1992
MeD, Hanzhou University, 1988
BS, Hangzhou University, 1985
Specialties
- Decision making, social dilemmas, conflict management, leadership, organizational citizenship behavior, employee turnover, cross-cultural management.
2007年2月1日星期四
exchange theory
属于社会学研究中的社会行动范式。
背景:George Ritzer借用科学哲学家库恩提出的“范式”概念,提出了社会学是一门与自然科学有着重大区别的科学的观点:社会学是一门具有多元范式的科学。他指出了三种基本范式:
1、社会事实范式
涂尔干的社会学理论以及当代的结构功能主义和社会冲突理论
2、社会释义范式
韦伯的社会学理论、帕森斯(Parsons)提出的“社会行动理论”以及米德、库利等人的著作引 发的符号互动主义理论
3、社会行动范式
霍曼斯(Homans)的社会交换理论
George Graen
![](http://bp0.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RcIKud-D6dI/AAAAAAAAADE/gZJdgCuRapo/s0-d/Graen.jpg)
began his career at the University of Minnesota (Minneapolis), where he published two articles in Journal of Applied Psychology, won a James McKeen Cattell Award from the Society of Industrial Organizational Psychology, and a McKinsey Award for doctorial dissertation, before he received his Ph.D. in Organizational Psychology. In 1967 he joined the Psychology Department and the Labor and Industrial Relations Center faculties at the University of Illinois (Champaign). In 1977, he was appointed Department Head and founded the International Leadership Center at the University of Cincinnati. In 1984 he received the first Japanese funded Johnson Wax Fulbright Research Fellowship. For the last ten years he and his cross-cultural research and consulting team have been engaged in projects to understand business ventures in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan and to help build effective local “Third Cultures” to enhance their sustainable competitiveness. In 1997 he was named the Gene Brauns Endowed Chair Professor of International Management at the University of Louisiana. He has published over one hundred and seventy-five professional articles and books.
2007年1月30日星期二
probabilisitc process
from Explaining Organizational Behavior
2007年1月29日星期一
Neal Schumitt
![](http://bp0.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rb49zfbH19I/AAAAAAAAACQ/Itn5_bwxImk/s0-d/Schmitt.gif)
Research interests/Areas of expertise
- Personnel selection, performance appraisal, job attitudes and decision making
Bio(s)
- Professor Schmitt received his Ph.D. degree from Purdue University in 1972. His research interests include personnel selection and test validation, performance appraisal, job attitudes, and decision making. Schmitt has served as consultant to the National Association of Secondary School Principals, SOHIO, Ford Motor Company, Haworth, Marathon, National Institute of Occupation Safety and Health, and various city and county governments. He is the past editor of the Journal of Applied Psychology and has published numerous articles in journals such as Personnel Psychology, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, and the Academy of Management Journal. He is a member of the Academy of Management, the American Psychological Association, and the Society of Organizational Behavior.
Lawrence B. Mohr
orthodoxy and ...
![](http://bp2.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rb3yTPbH16I/AAAAAAAAABs/eskFeL_1dmg/s0-d/Christmas+Skype.png)
Because this orthodoxy is so dominant and strong, its adherents often take it for granted as right and self-evident. Rival perspectives from the same paradigm or outside its bounds appear as satellites defining alternative points of view. Their impact upon the orthodoxy, however, is rarely very significant. They are seldom strong enough to establish themselves as anything more than a somewhat deviant set of approaches. As a result the possibilities which they offer are rarely explored, let alone understood.
-- Burrell and Morgan
2007年1月28日星期日
Phil Podsakoff
![](http://bp3.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rb31AfbH17I/AAAAAAAAAB4/4QdjE55UG_A/s0-d/Fax+Skype.png)
John F. Mee Chair of Management
Professor of Organizational Behavior & Human Resources
Research Interests:
Leadership Behavior and Effectiveness
Substitutes for Leadership
Antecedents & Consequences of Organizational Citizenship Behavior
Relationships Between Employee Attitudes
Effects of Monetary & Non-Monetary Reward Systems
Social Power & Influence Processes
Issues in Field Research Methodologies
Professor Podsakoff is an expert in the fields of leadership and behavioral processes in organizations. He is internationally known for his research on transactional and transformational leadership processes in organizations, power and social influence processes, the effects of various "substitutes" for leadership, and the antecedents and consequences of employee "citizenship" behaviors.
2007年1月27日星期六
Jennifer Chatman
![](http://bp0.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RbwFs_bH15I/AAAAAAAAABg/00bR9VtdOYk/s0-d/chatman.jpg)
Paul J. Cortese Distinguished Professor of Management
Haas Organizational Behavior and Industrial Relations Group
BA, psychology, University of California, Berkeley
Ph.D., business administration, University of California, Berkeley
- 2005 “Most Influential Paper Award,” 1997-2000, Academy of Management , Conflict Management Division f or “Being different yet feeling similar: The influence of demographic composition and organizational culture on work processes and outcomes” published in Admin. Science Quarterly, 1998,43 (4): 749-780 (with J. Polzer, S. Barsade , & M. Neale).
- 2004 Accenture Award, for the article that “made the most important contribution to improving the practice of management” in California Management Review for “Leading by Leveraging Culture” (with S. Cha).
- 1998 L.L. Cummings Scholar Award, Academy of Management Organizational Behavior Division, awarded for “outstanding achievement to one researcher in early mid-career.”
- 1997 Administrative Science Quarterly Award for Scholarly Contribution, for “the article that had the most impact on the field of organizational behavior over the past five years,” for Mixing and matching people and organizations: Selection and socialization in public accounting firms, published in ASQ in 1991.
- 1996 Schwabacher Research Award, Haas School of Business.
- 1994 Ascendant Scholar Award, Western Academy of Management.
- 1991 Best Paper Award, Academy of Management Organization and Management Theory Division for “Assessing the relationship between industry characteristics and organizational culture: How different can you be?” (with K. Jehn).
- 1989 Outstanding Paper Based on a Dissertation Award, Academy of Management Organizational Behavior Division for “Mixing and Matching People and Organizations: Selection and Socialization in Public Accounting Firms.”
2007年1月26日星期五
alternative...
what 'alternative' truely means is that you have to make a difference of your own to make the world with you a little better than the one without you.
People tend to attach to what has already been said or done, coz they don't have to spend much time figuring out how to do it on their own, and this creates the 'trap' of knowledge, that is, the more you know sth, the more unlikely you will try to overcome it. Yet, if we look at the things that got all the applause, it would not be surprising that what we discover are things never known, words never spoken, and theories never conjured up, et al..
Well then, after all these thoughts, time to do sth different.
Katherine J. Klein
![](http://bp0.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RbnyhvbH14I/AAAAAAAAABU/QEa1sK94T-g/s0-d/klein_katherine.jpg)
Edward H. Bowman Professor; Professor of Management
PhD, University of Texas, 1984; BA, Yale University
Research Areas
Multilevel organizational theory and research; organizational psychology; team composition, leadership, and effectiveness; organizational innovation processes
Current Projects
Shock trauma research project: Team leadership, team performance, and individual learning in a dynamic setting; Team composition, team leadership, and team social networks over time; Stock options and employee attitudes.
Academic Positions Held
Wharton: 2004–present(named Edward H. Bowman Professor, 2005). Previous appointments: Department of Psychology, University of Maryland. Visiting appointments: Graduate School of Business, Stanford University
Career and Recent Professional Awards; Teaching Awards
Army Research Institute Research Grant, 2
2007年1月25日星期四
Anne Tsui
![](http://bp1.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/Rbjb-PbH13I/AAAAAAAAABI/bApG1X9DejY/s0-d/image006.jpg)
Anne S. Tsui is Motorola Professor of International Management at the W.P. Carey School of Business, Arizona State University.
She was the 14th Editor of the Academy of Management Journal (1997-1999) and is a Fellow of the Academy of Management since 1997. She serves or has served on the editorial review boards of most premier management journals. She is the founding President of the International Association for Chinese Management Research (www.iacmr.org), and is the Editor in Chief of the journal Management and Organization Review (www.blackwell-synergy.com/loi/more), which is dedicated to publishing China related management and organization research.
Dr. Tsui has conducted research on a variety of topics, including managerial and leadership effectiveness, performance assessment, human resource department effectiveness, self-regulation, employee-organization relationship, and demographic diversity. Her current research programs include employment relationships and corporate culture and leadership in firms operating in the Chinese setting. Results of her research findings have appeared in journals such as the Academy of Management Journal, Administrative Science Quarterly, Organization Science, Personnel Psychology, Industrial Relations, Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, Journal of Management, Human Relations and Work and Occupations. The article, "Being different: Relational demography and organizational attachment" published in Administrative Science Quarterly, 1992, won the Outstanding Publication in Organizational Behavior Award in 1993 and five years later, the ASQ Scholarly Contribution Award in 1998. The article "Alternative approaches to employee-organization relationships: Does investment in employees pay off?" published in Academy of Management Journal, 1997, won the Best AMJ paper in 1998 and also the Scholarly Achievement Award, from the Human Resource Division, Academy of Management, 1998.
Dr. Tsui is 87th (among 778) most cited scientists in business and economics (Jan 1993 to Jan 2003) and 21st of the top 100 most cited scholars in management (1981-2001).
Dr. Tsui has taught executive courses on leadership, organizational culture, and human resource management topics for many organizations, including various Education, Social Welfare, and Housing departments of the Hong Kong Government; Allergan Asia, Ltd.; Fluor Daniel Corporation; TRW, Inc.; Hughes Aircraft; Leadership Education for Asian Pacific Professionals; Sharp Healthcare; Silicon Systems, Inc.; and United States Postal Service.
2007年1月23日星期二
Donald C. Hambrick
![](http://bp3.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RbYnfPbH12I/AAAAAAAAAA8/7B-8bF9w7T0/s0-d/biodon1.jpg)
the growth of management philosophies and China's case
Now in the 21st century, we see similar issues raised and discussed in China. Is there one best way? Until the economic reform, there was one way, even if not the best way. Now, many flowers bloom. The results of this study are clear that all the styles have a place in China's transitional period -- this point in time. What does the future hold? The answer is yet to be found.
---- Anne S. Tsui, Hui Wang, & Katherine Xin et al.
2007年1月21日星期日
W. Richard Scott
![](http://bp2.blogger.com/_pXzBoz76u9k/RbO26vbH11I/AAAAAAAAAAs/9cU4C8eb1C4/s0-d/scott36.jpg)
W. Richard (Dick) Scott is Professor Emeritus in the Department of Sociology. He has spent his entire career at Stanford.
He is the author or co-author of many scholarly books and articles including, most recently, Institutions and Organizations, 2001, 2nd ed., Sage, and Organizations and Organizing: Rational, Natural and Open System Perspectives (with Gerald F. Davis), Prentice-Hall, 2007.
He is currently involved in theoretical work bringing together institutional theory in organizations with social movement theory; and in conducting empirical research on institutional change at the community level with collaborators from School of Education and institutional conflicts at the global level with collaborators from the School of Engineering.
2007年1月20日星期六
John P. Campbell
James G. March
James G. March is Professor Emeritus at Stanford University. He is best known for his research on organizations and organizational decision making. March is highly respected for his broad theoretical perspective which combined theories from Psychology and other behavioural sciences. He collaborated with the Cognitive psychologist Herbert Simon on several works on organization theory. March is also known for his seminal work on the behavioural perspective on Theory of the firm along with Richard Cyert (1963). In 1972 March worked together with Olsen and Cohen on the systemic-anarchic perspective of organizational decision making known as the Garbage Can Model.
James G March is the father of four children and the grandfather of seven. Since 1953, he has served on the faculties of the Carnegie Institute of Technology, the University of California, Irvine, and (since 1970) Stanford University. He has been elected to the National Academy of Science, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, and the National Academy of Education, and has been a member of the National Science Board.
Bibliography
- (1972) Michael D. Cohen, James G. March, Johan P. Olsen A Garbage Can Model of Organizational Choice Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 17, No. 1. (Mar., 1972), pp. 1-25.[JSTOR] [particularly pp.1-3 & 9-13]
March's Books
- An introduction to the theory and measurement of influence (1955)
- Autonomy As a Factor in Group Organization (1980) ISBN 0-405-12980-7
- Ambiguity and Choice in Organizations (1980) ISBN 82-00-01960-8
- Decisions and Organizations (1988) ISBN 0-631-16856-7
- Rediscovering Institutions (1989) ISBN 0-02-920115-2
- A Primer on Decision Making (1994) ISBN 0-02-920035-0
- Democratic Governance (1995) ISBN 0-02-874054-8
- The Pursuit of Organizational Intelligence (1998) ISBN 0-631-21102-0
- On Leadership (2005) ISBN 1-4051-3247-7
Prize-winning Articles for 2005 and the First Two Decades of AMR
2. Upper Echelons: The Organization As a Reflection of Its Top Managers by Donald C. Hambrick and Phyllis A. Mason, 1984
3. An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust by Roger C. Mayer, James H. Davis, and David F. Schoorman, 1995
Thomas Luckmann
Thomas Luckmann (b. 1927) was Professor for Sociology at the University of Constance in Germany. Since 1994 he is professor emeritus. He is well known for the book The Social Construction of Reality (1966, together with Peter L. Berger) and for Structures of the Life-World (1982, together with Alfred Schütz).
Research areas of Luckmann include the Sociology of knowledge, the sociology of religion, the sociology of communication and the philosophy of science.
His works include:
- The Social Construction of Reality. A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge (1966, with Peter L. Berger)
- The Invisible Religion. The Problem of Religion in Modern Society (1967)
- The Sociology of Language (1975)
- Structures of the Life-World (1982, with Alfred Schütz)
- Life-World and Social Realities (1983)
Peter Michael Blau
A THEORY OF SOCIAL EXCHANGE
2007年1月19日星期五
Goffman's observation about expectations
理论的局限
相对同一个角落,用不同角度的探照灯也会产生截然不同的效果,社会科学的研究,在很大程度上就是要找到一个很好的角度,能够探照到尽可能多的内容,看到从别的角度不能看到的东西,只有到这样的程度,才可以称得上有所建树。
最近看到Donald T. Campbell为Case Study Research一书写的foreword,里面提到“plausible rival hypotheses”,很受启发,因为研究工作正是在不断地进行不同理论的比较中获得进步,如果你发现的理论可以用另一个理论解释,那么至少说明你的理论只是提供了一个视角,并没有提出更加新的东西,所作的贡献相比那些寻找出新内容的理论来说是略逊一筹的。对于后一种理论,在实际操作中很重要的一点就是研究的控制,只有你实施了良好的控制,才能排除其他可能的解释,做出自身独特的理论贡献。